Evolution vs Black Cube: The ‘illegal markets’ case
Evolution settled with the law firm that sent the 2021 report to regulators. Black Cube’s dismissal request remains pending.
The Evolution vs Black Cube lawsuit has narrowed with a confidential settlement between Evolution, the live casino supplier behind Crazy Time, and law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky. The firm sent the 2021 report to U.S. regulators and disclosed the deal on Nov. 17, 2026, as a New Jersey court heard Black Cube’s bid for dismissal.

KEY FACTS AT A GLANCE
- Settlement Calcagni & Kanefsky’s counsel disclosed the deal on Nov. 17. The terms are confidential.
- Pending decision Black Cube is asking the court to dismiss Evolution’s claims under New Jersey’s anti-SLAPP law.
- Playtech’s role Its subsidiary commissioned the investigation. A June court order left Playtech outside the case.
Who was behind the Black Cube report?
Evolution supplies live casino games to operators. Players may know its titles, including Crazy Time, MONOPOLY Live, Lightning Roulette and Ice Fishing. The casino operator runs the site where players sign in and place their bets.
Black Cube, a private intelligence firm, wrote the report. Playtech Software Limited, a subsidiary of rival supplier Playtech, commissioned the investigation. Calcagni & Kanefsky delivered the report to state gaming officials.
-
Law firm sends the report to New Jersey and later provides it to Pennsylvania. Evolution sues in December.
-
Appeals court sets aside the initial client-disclosure order and sends the issue back.
-
New Jersey closes its inquiry. Pennsylvania officials say they are taking no action at that time.
-
Evolution adds Black Cube as a defendant.
-
Evolution identifies Playtech Software Limited as the commissioning party. Playtech confirms its role.
-
Pennsylvania records decision cites the director’s September description of an ongoing investigation.
-
Judge declines the request to add Playtech, with room for a renewed request.
-
Black Cube files the Spectrum review.
-
Counsel discloses the confidential law-firm settlement.
-
Decision on Black Cube’s anti-SLAPP request remains pending.
What the 2021 report alleged
The report alleged that operators offered Evolution’s games in countries under U.S. sanctions and in other restricted jurisdictions. It also alleged that Evolution knew where people were playing and benefited from the activity. Evolution disputed the allegations and said casino operators control player access.
According to the complaint, the law firm sent the report to New Jersey’s Division of Gaming Enforcement on Nov. 12, 2021. In a sworn account, the firm said Pennsylvania requested it on Nov. 30 and received it a few days later. Evolution sued the attorneys and unidentified parties in December.
What New Jersey and Pennsylvania did
In February 2024, Evolution announced that New Jersey had closed its investigation without further action. Evolution said the Division found no evidence that it authorized, promoted, permitted or materially benefited from operators offering its games in markets the Division considered prohibited. The state is also home to Evolution’s Atlantic City live studio operations.
Pennsylvania enforcement officials took no action at the time of their Feb. 22, 2024 letter. In a December 2025 public records decision, the state’s Office of Open Records cited sworn evidence from the enforcement director. He had described the requested records as part of an ongoing investigation that September.
Evolution later said both states closed their investigations in February 2024. For Pennsylvania, the records decision provides the state’s account through September 2025. The public records reviewed provide no later disposition.
How the court case identified Playtech
At first, a court ordered the law firm to name its client. In January 2023, a New Jersey appeals court set that order aside and told the trial court to assess the strength of Evolution’s claims first. After further disclosure proceedings identified Black Cube, Evolution says it added the firm as a defendant on June 11, 2025.
In August 2025, Black Cube submitted an affidavit citing covert recordings, as Bloomberg Law reported. Black Cube argued the recordings supported its claims. Evolution challenged their reliability.
In September 2025, the trial court ordered Black Cube to identify its client. New Jersey’s Supreme Court declined to hear Black Cube’s appeal and denied a stay, according to NEXT.io. On Oct. 21, Evolution named Playtech Software Limited. Playtech confirmed that its subsidiary had commissioned the investigation and rejected Evolution’s account of its purpose.
Evolution then moved to add Playtech and others in April 2026. On June 5, Judge John Porto denied the request without prejudice, leaving room for a renewed request. According to Playtech’s interim report, the court would address the existing claims first.
Why the Spectrum review came up at the hearing
On Sept. 8, 2026, Black Cube filed a 2022 review that Evolution had commissioned from Spectrum Gaming Group. Spectrum reproduced some access in places where operator contracts restricted it and identified gaps in monitoring. Its tests did not substantiate the examples it examined from countries under U.S. sanctions. The review treated contract restrictions and the New Jersey regulator’s definition of a prohibited market separately.
What New Jersey’s anti-SLAPP ruling can decide
New Jersey’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act lets defendants seek early dismissal of claims tied to certain speech or communications with government bodies. Black Cube argues that the report is true and its conduct qualifies for protection, according to NEXT.io’s hearing coverage.
The court will consider whether the law covers the challenged claims, whether an exception applies and whether the claims meet the legal threshold to proceed. It can dismiss all or part of a challenged claim with prejudice, which bars refiling that claim. Claims that survive can continue, subject to any appeal.
Timing matters because Evolution filed suit in 2021, the law took effect in October 2023, and Evolution added Black Cube in 2025. The statute applies to civil actions filed or claims asserted on or after its effective date. The judge will decide how it applies here.
As of Nov. 19, 2026, CasinoBeats reported that Black Cube remained the only defendant and its challenge was pending. If claims against Black Cube survive, Evolution could ask again to add Playtech. That request would require a separate court decision.
FAQs
What did Black Cube’s 2021 report allege?
It alleged that Evolution’s games reached sanctioned or otherwise prohibited markets and that the supplier knowingly benefited. Evolution disputed the allegations and said operators control player access.
Who wrote, commissioned and sent the report?
Black Cube prepared the report. Playtech Software Limited commissioned the investigation, and New Jersey law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky provided the report to gaming officials in New Jersey and Pennsylvania.
What did New Jersey and Pennsylvania do?
New Jersey closed its investigation in February 2024 without further action, according to Evolution. Pennsylvania officials took no action that February. A December 2025 records decision cited sworn evidence that the requested records were part of an ongoing investigation that September.
What did Evolution settle?
Evolution settled its dispute with Calcagni & Kanefsky. The law firm’s counsel disclosed the deal on Nov. 17, 2026. The terms are confidential, and Black Cube’s dismissal request remained pending as of Nov. 19.
Where does Playtech fit into the case?
Playtech confirmed that a subsidiary commissioned Black Cube’s investigation. The June 5 order left Playtech outside the lawsuit. Evolution would need court approval to add Playtech if it renews the request.
What could the anti-SLAPP ruling change for players?
The ruling will determine whether some or all of the challenged civil claims can proceed. Game availability depends on the casino operator and the licensing rules where it offers the games.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- The state responses differed — New Jersey closed its investigation. Pennsylvania took no action in February 2024, and a 2025 state decision cited evidence of an ongoing investigation that September.
- The next court decision concerns Black Cube — The judge can dismiss challenged claims or let them continue. Playtech would need a separate ruling to join the case.
Sources
- Evolution AB v. Marra, A-3341-21 — Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division
- Final determination, AP 2025-2914 — Pennsylvania Office of Open Records
- June 5, 2026 order — Superior Court of New Jersey, Atlantic County
- Uniform Public Expression Protection Act, P.L. 2023, c.155 — New Jersey State Law Library
- November 2021 investigative report — Black Cube
- Spectrum Gaming Group report, filed September 8, 2026 — Superior Court of New Jersey court exhibit
- November 24, 2021 response to the allegations — Evolution
- New Jersey investigation closure announcement — Evolution
- October 21, 2025 statement on Black Cube’s client — Evolution
- October 21, 2025 response to Evolution — Playtech market announcement
- April 9, 2026 statement on the motion to add Playtech — Evolution
- 2026 half-year results, legal update — Playtech
- Live casino and game shows — Evolution
- Ice Fishing’s U.S. debut — Evolution
- August 2025 coverage of Black Cube’s affidavit — Bloomberg Law
- October 2025 reporting on the disclosure appeal — NEXT.io
- November 17, 2026 hearing coverage — NEXT.io
- November 19, 2026 settlement and motion update — CasinoBeats



